Internet Archive Loses Court Appeal in Fight Over Online Lending Library
The dispute started in the early days of the pandemic when the organization expanded access to a free online collection of books.
When libraries across the country temporarily closed in the early days of the pandemic, the Internet Archive, an organization that digitizes and archives materials like web pages and music, had the idea to make its library of scanned books free to read in an online database.
The question of that library’s legality became a long-running saga that may have finally ended on Wednesday, when an appeals court affirmed that the Internet Archive violated copyright laws by redistributing those books without a licensing agreement.
The decision, by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in Manhattan, is a victory for the major book publishers that brought the lawsuit in 2020, and could set a precedent over the lawfulness of broader digital archives.
“The defendant attempted to do what no one had done before, which was to call unauthorized distribution of entire books ‘lending’ without permission,” said Maria A. Pallante, president of the Association of American Publishers, which helped coordinate the industry response. “Obviously we are delighted” with the decision, she said.
