As noted by Retraction Watch, Elsevier's Ain Shams Engineering Journal withdrew two papers exploring dam failures after complaints from Flow Science,

Academic papers yanked after authors found to have used unlicensed software

submited by

Style Pass

2024-11-14 23:00:06

As noted by Retraction Watch, Elsevier's Ain Shams Engineering Journal withdrew two papers exploring dam failures after complaints from Flow Science, the Santa Fe, New Mexico-based maker of a computational fluid dynamics application called FLOW-3D.

"Following an editorial investigation as a result of a complaint from the software distributor, the authors admitted that the use of professional software, FLOW-3D program for the results published in the article, was made without a license from the developer," a note from the journal's editor-in-chief explains.

"One of the conditions of submission of a paper for publication is that the article does not violate any intellectual property rights of any person or entity and that the use of any software is made under a license or permission from the software owner."

The academic publishing giant lists various infractions that can lead to the removal of a paper. Beyond copyright infringement, libel, and privacy violations, these include significant errors, ethical violations, and conflicts of interest. The use of generative AI, not specifically mentioned, can also lead to a retraction.