Notifications in 46 and beyond
One of the things we’re tackling as part of the STF infrastructure initiative is improving notifications. Other platforms have advanced significantly in this area over the past decade, while we still have more or less the same notifications we had since the early GNOME 3 days, both in terms of API and feature set. There’s plenty to do here 🙂
As part of the effort to port GNOME Shell to mobile Jonas looked into the delta between what we currently support and what we’d need for a more modern notification experience. Some of these limitations are specific to GNOME’s implementation, while others are relevant to all desktops.
As of GNOME 45 there’s no clear identification on notification bubbles which app they were sent by. Sometimes it’s hard to tell where a notification is coming from, which can be annoying when managing notifications in Settings. This also has potential security implications, since the lack of identification makes it trivial to impersonate other apps.
GNOME Shell can’t play notification sounds in all cases, depending on the API the app is using (see below). Apps not primarily targeting GNOME Shell directly tend to play sounds themselves because they can’t rely on the system always doing it (it’s an optional feature of the XDG Notification API which different desktops handle differently). This works, but it’s messy for app developers because it’s hard to test and they have to implement a fallback sound played by the app. From a user perspective it’s annoying that you can’t always tell where sounds are coming from because they’re not necessarily tied to a notification bubble. There’s also no central place to manage the notification behavior and it doesn’t respect Do Not Disturb.
